The recent comments by U.S. Vice President JD Vance regarding the rights and limitations of green card holders have reignited discussions on permanent residency in the United States. Vance emphasized that holding a green card does not guarantee an indefinite stay in the country, a statement that has drawn attention to the legal conditions attached to permanent residency.
This debate comes amid President Donald Trump’s proposal of a ‘gold card’ program, which aims to allow wealthy investors to buy a U.S. residency permit for $5 million, potentially replacing the EB-5 immigrant investor visa.
At the center of this discussion is the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a pro-Palestinian activist whose green card was revoked by the Trump administration due to national security concerns. His arrest has highlighted how permanent residency can be revoked under certain conditions, particularly in cases where an individual is seen as a security threat.
This article explores the rights and responsibilities of green card holders, the circumstances under which their residency may be revoked, and the broader implications of the U.S. government’s stance on immigration.
Green Card Holders: Rights vs. Citizenship
While a green card provides permanent residency, it does not grant the same rights and privileges as U.S. citizenship. The key differences include:
| Rights & Privileges | Green Card Holders | U.S. Citizens |
|---|---|---|
| Live and work in the U.S. | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Travel freely in and out of the U.S. | ✅ Yes (with restrictions) | ✅ Yes |
| Vote in elections | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Hold a U.S. passport | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Run for public office | ❌ No | ✅ Yes (except President/Vice President) |
| Protection from deportation | ❌ No (Can be revoked) | ✅ Yes |
| Sponsor family members for green cards | ✅ Yes (Limited) | ✅ Yes (More extensive options) |
Although green card holders enjoy many benefits, their residency is subject to revocation under certain legal conditions.
Conditions for Green Card Revocation
Green cards are not permanent by default and can be revoked under specific circumstances, including:
1. Criminal Offenses
- Felonies such as fraud, drug trafficking, violent crimes, or terrorism-related activities can lead to immediate deportation.
- Multiple misdemeanors or crimes of moral turpitude (e.g., theft, domestic violence, tax evasion) can also result in green card loss.
2. Abandonment of Residency
- If a green card holder leaves the U.S. for an extended period without obtaining a Reentry Permit, they may be deemed to have abandoned their residency.
- Staying outside the U.S. for more than one year without proper documentation could lead to green card cancellation.
3. Immigration Fraud
- Providing false information during the green card application process (e.g., fake marriages, false work history) can result in revocation.
- Engaging in fraudulent activities after obtaining residency can also lead to deportation.
4. Failure to Comply with U.S. Laws
- Green card holders must obey all state and federal laws.
- Engaging in activities deemed as threats to national security, such as terrorist affiliations or espionage, can lead to immediate removal.
5. Failure to Notify USCIS of Address Change
- U.S. immigration law requires green card holders to inform USCIS of any change of address within 10 days of moving.
- Failing to do so can result in fines, penalties, or even deportation in extreme cases.
Responsibilities of Green Card Holders
While green card holders enjoy many rights, they also have specific obligations under U.S. law.
1. Obeying U.S. Laws
- Permanent residents must follow all federal, state, and local laws.
- Violating laws can lead to legal penalties or deportation.
2. Filing Income Tax Returns
- Green card holders must report their worldwide income and pay U.S. taxes.
- Failure to file tax returns can affect future citizenship applications and even lead to legal consequences.
3. Supporting Democratic Governance
- Green card holders are expected to support the democratic system of the U.S.
- However, they cannot vote in federal, state, or local elections.
4. Registering for Selective Service
- Male green card holders aged 18 to 25 must register for Selective Service, which is the U.S. military draft system.
- Failure to register may impact future citizenship applications.
Trump’s ‘Gold Card’ Proposal: A New Immigration Path?
President Donald Trump’s proposed ‘gold card’ program has sparked debate over alternative residency options for wealthy immigrants.
Key Features of the ‘Gold Card’
- Investment Requirement: Wealthy foreigners can obtain residency by investing $5 million.
- Pathway to Citizenship: Potential replacement for the EB-5 Investor Visa.
- Economic Impact: Designed to attract high-net-worth individuals to the U.S. economy.
While supporters argue that this plan could boost economic growth, critics claim it favors the wealthy while ignoring middle-class immigrants and skilled workers.
Understanding the Limitations of Permanent Residency
The discussion surrounding green card rights highlights an important distinction: permanent residency is not absolute. Green card holders must comply with U.S. laws, maintain residency, and fulfill their obligations to avoid losing their status.
With the rise of new immigration proposals, such as the gold card program, the debate on who should be allowed to stay in the U.S. continues to evolve. While green cards provide many benefits, they also come with responsibilities—and failure to meet those responsibilities can result in revocation.
For those seeking long-term stability in the U.S., naturalization remains the most secure path to full citizenship and protection from deportation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Can a green card holder stay in the U.S. indefinitely?
No. Green card holders must follow residency laws and can lose their status due to criminal activity, prolonged absences, or immigration violations.
Q2: Can a green card holder be deported?
Yes. Green card holders can be removed from the U.S. if they commit serious crimes, fail to meet residency requirements, or engage in fraud.
Q3: Can green card holders vote in U.S. elections?
No. Only U.S. citizens can vote in federal, state, and local elections.
Q4: How can a green card holder become a U.S. citizen?
Green card holders can apply for naturalization after living in the U.S. for 5 years (or 3 years if married to a U.S. citizen) and meeting other eligibility criteria.
Q5: What should green card holders do to maintain their status?
- Follow all U.S. laws and avoid criminal activities.
- File annual tax returns with the IRS.
- Do not stay outside the U.S. for extended periods without proper documentation.
- Update USCIS with any change of address.
Click here to know more.
Kishan is a knowledgeable writer specializing in agriculture and the latest government job recruitments, delivering clear and insightful content to inform and empower readers.
