Personal income tax remains a critical topic in Budget 2025 discussions, as taxpayers continue to seek relief in a landscape where revenue generation and fiscal policies intersect. Despite introducing new tax regimes and minor adjustments in previous years, the government has been reluctant to make significant changes to personal income tax laws. This article explores the factors behind this hesitation, the challenges faced by taxpayers, and the broader implications for the economy.
The Role of Personal Income Tax in Government Revenues
Personal income tax forms a substantial and reliable part of the government’s revenue stream, surpassing corporate tax collections in recent years. These revenues enable the government to fund various infrastructure projects, public welfare programs, and social services.
| Revenue Source | Share in Total Revenue |
|---|---|
| Personal Income Tax | Higher than Corporate Tax |
| Corporate Tax | Steady but lower |
| Indirect Taxes (e.g., GST) | Significant contribution |
While taxpayers may demand relief through reduced rates and expanded exemptions, every adjustment in income tax laws impacts the government’s fiscal stability, making it cautious about implementing sweeping changes.
The New Tax Regime: Simplification with Trade-offs
The government introduced a new tax regime aimed at simplifying compliance and offering lower tax rates. However, this comes with the condition that taxpayers must forego common deductions, such as those for housing loan interest, investments in social security instruments, and child education expenses.
Key Features of the New Tax Regime:
- Reduced tax rates across various slabs.
- No deductions or rebates for investments or expenses.
- Enhanced benefits for incomes up to ₹7 lakh with tax-free provisions.
While the new regime benefits individuals with limited deductions, taxpayers accustomed to the older system often find it less advantageous, especially those with substantial investments in tax-saving schemes.
Challenges with Revising Personal Income Tax
The government’s reluctance to reduce personal income tax rates stems from several interconnected challenges:
1. Revenue Losses from Tax Reliefs
Every exemption, rebate, or tax cut translates to reduced revenue, directly impacting the government’s ability to fund essential programs. With the majority of income tax revenue collected from individuals earning over ₹10 lakh annually, any reduction would disproportionately affect high-income earners and the government’s fiscal capacity.
2. Inflation and Its Impact
While revising tax thresholds to account for inflation seems logical, core inflation (excluding food and energy) has been relatively stable. However, food inflation remains problematic, affecting lower-income households more severely than those within the tax net.
3. Compliance Over Tax Rates
For entrepreneurs, start-ups, and small business owners, the complexity of tax laws often outweighs concerns about high rates. The introduction of a presumptive tax regime, which simplifies compliance by taxing a fixed percentage of income, could ease this burden and make taxation more efficient.
Benefits of Taxes: What Do Taxpayers Get in Return?
Taxes are not just a financial obligation; they are the foundation of public services and welfare programs. Personal income tax revenues are channeled into:
- Infrastructure Development: Roads, railways, and other critical infrastructure projects.
- Subsidized Services: Affordable food, healthcare, and education for underprivileged sections.
- Social Redistribution: Narrowing wealth disparities through targeted welfare programs.
Mr. Rahul Garg, an advisor to Assocham, emphasizes that the benefits citizens receive from these expenditures far outweigh the cumulative income tax contributions. Plugging leakages in resource allocation could enhance the efficiency of these programs.
The Government’s Perspective: Balancing Welfare and Fiscal Stability
The reluctance to introduce major income tax cuts stems from the need to balance economic priorities. Reducing tax rates or expanding exemptions without offsetting revenue sources could widen fiscal deficits and strain public finances.
Why the Government Prefers Caution:
- Dependence on Taxpayers: Most income tax revenue comes from those earning above ₹10 lakh annually.
- Redistributive Goals: Funds are needed to support social welfare programs.
- Economic Stability: Lower revenues could disrupt fiscal planning and infrastructure investments.
Conclusion
Budget 2025 highlights the complexities of income tax reforms, where the government must balance the demands of taxpayers with fiscal responsibilities. While the new tax regime offers simplified options, challenges like inflation, compliance burdens, and revenue needs shape the reluctance to introduce significant cuts. For taxpayers, understanding these dynamics can foster informed discussions and realistic expectations.
FAQs on Budget 2025 and Income Tax Policies
1. What is the difference between the old and new tax regimes?
The old tax regime allows taxpayers to claim deductions and rebates, such as for housing loans and investments, while the new regime offers lower tax rates without these benefits.
2. Why has the government not reduced personal income tax rates?
Reducing income tax rates would result in significant revenue losses, impacting the government’s ability to fund welfare programs and infrastructure projects.
3. How does inflation affect income tax policies?
Inflation erodes purchasing power, leading to calls for higher tax thresholds. However, core inflation has been stable, reducing the urgency for changes.
4. What is a presumptive tax regime?
A presumptive tax regime simplifies compliance by taxing a fixed percentage of income, often benefiting small businesses and entrepreneurs.
5. Who benefits most from the new tax regime?
Taxpayers with lower incomes or minimal deductions find the new regime advantageous due to reduced tax rates.
6. Why does the government prioritize personal income tax revenues?
Personal income tax is a reliable and steady source of revenue, funding key social and infrastructure projects critical to national development.
Click here to know more.
Kishan is a knowledgeable writer specializing in agriculture and the latest government job recruitments, delivering clear and insightful content to inform and empower readers.